Contact us
Please note that we cannot offer Legal aid
Understanding covert recordings in custody disputes
Legal risks and privacy concerns of covert recordings
Common Law vs. French Law – expat perspective
Strategic alternatives & practical guidance
PacisLexis Family Law
Covert recordings
When you’re in the middle of a custody battle, every decision can feel like the difference between winning and losing time with your child. Evidence matters—but so does the legality of how it’s obtained.
If you’re considering using secret recordings in your family case, our experienced legal team can help assess whether it’s the right move or a dangerous gamble.
Schedule a confidential consultation with us—appointments available within 48 hours.
Covert recordings in family law
Understanding covert recordings in custody disputes
What are covert recordings, and why are they used in custody battles?
Covert recordings refer to audio or video recordings made without the knowledge or consent of the person being recorded.
In custody battles, they are often used by one parent to try to prove abuse, neglect, or inappropriate behaviour by the other parent.
These recordings can involve private conversations, interactions with the child, or behaviour exhibited by the other parent when they think no one is watching.
Are these recordings admissible in family court?
Admissibility varies greatly by jurisdiction. In many common law countries, such as the U.S. and the U.K., some courts may admit covert recordings if they believe the content is in the child’s best interest.
However, they may also be rejected due to how they were obtained—especially if privacy laws were violated.
In France and many civil law jurisdictions, unauthorized recordings are generally inadmissible and may be illegal.
What kinds of recordings are commonly attempted in custody cases?
Examples include audio recordings of phone calls, video recordings during exchanges, hidden camera footage within the home, and surveillance-style recordings of daily interactions.
Some parents even try to use baby monitors, smart home devices, or GPS trackers to gather what they consider proof.
Do judges trust covert recordings?
Even when allowed, covert recordings are scrutinised for authenticity and context. Judges often question the motive and ethics behind making them.
If the recording appears manipulative or edited, it could damage the parent’s credibility rather than help their case.
Can covert recordings backfire legally?
Absolutely.
If made in a jurisdiction where such recordings are illegal or considered a breach of privacy, the recording parent could face criminal charges or sanctions, including limitations on custody.
Furthermore, the act of secretly recording can reflect poorly on that parent’s behaviour and intentions.
Covert recordings in family law
Legal risks and privacy concerns of covert recordings
Is it legal to record someone without their consent?
In common law countries like the United States, legality depends on whether it’s a one-party or two-party consent state.
In one-party consent states, only one person (even the person doing the recording) needs to be aware. In two-party consent states, all parties involved must agree.
In France, however, covert recordings without consent are generally illegal under Article 226-1 of the French Criminal Code, especially in private settings.
Can recording someone lead to criminal charges?
Yes.
If you record someone without proper legal justification or without consent in a jurisdiction that requires it, you can be charged with violating wiretap laws, privacy violations, or even stalking.
In France, the penalty for violating privacy laws can include up to a year in prison and a €45,000 fine.
Are there exceptions for child safety?
Some courts will consider illegally obtained recordings if they clearly demonstrate imminent harm or abuse to a child.
However, the exception is rare, and judges still often weigh this against the violation of privacy. In France, the law is less forgiving—even in cases involving minors.
What are the ethical risks of recording your partner?
Beyond legality, covert recording introduces a host of ethical issues.
It can damage trust between parents and even between parent and child, especially if the child learns they were recorded or used as bait.
It can also create a hostile environment, making future co-parenting more difficult.
Can private investigators legally record for you?
Private investigators may have more flexibility in surveillance, but they must still adhere to the law. They cannot legally record conversations without consent in two-party consent jurisdictions or in France.
Hiring a PI does not shield you from responsibility if the recordings were illegal.
Covert recordings in family law
Common Law vs. French Law – expat perspective
How do common law and French law differ regarding covert recordings?
In common law systems, such as in the U.S., Canada, or the UK, courts often use a discretionary standard.
A judge may admit recordings if they are deemed relevant and not overly prejudicial, particularly in the child’s best interest.
In contrast, French civil law treats the legality of the recording as paramount: illegally obtained evidence is generally inadmissible, regardless of its content.
Are covert recordings more accepted in the U.S. or UK courts than in France?
Yes!
While still controversial, U.S. and UK courts have, in specific custody cases, accepted covert recordings under a “best interests of the child” analysis.
French courts, by contrast, are bound by stricter privacy protections. Article 9 of the French Civil Code protects individual privacy, making it nearly impossible to use covert recordings—even in family court.
What challenges do expats face in custody battles involving both legal systems?
Expats with bi-national families often face cross-border legal issues.
For example, a French parent living in the U.S. may make a recording that’s legal under U.S. law but becomes problematic in a French custody proceeding.
Likewise, using evidence collected in France in a U.S. court can be complicated if the recording was illegal under French law.
Can recordings legally made abroad be used in a French court?
Not necessarily.
Even if a recording was legally made in another country, French courts may exclude it on the basis of privacy infringement or civil code violations.
The court evaluates whether the method of evidence collection aligns with French public order and rights to privacy.
How can an expat navigate these legal contradictions?
It is critical to consult a lawyer experienced in international family law.
They can help assess the risk of using or sharing a recording in either jurisdiction, and put a strategy in place accordingly—whether by finding alternate ways to prove a claim, or by pursuing legal admissibility under mutual agreements between jurisdictions.
Covert recordings in family law
Strategic alternatives and practical guidance
If using covert recordings is risky, what are safer alternatives?
Safer methods include:
- Documenting incidents with written logs
- Requesting child custody evaluations or third-party observations
- Using supervised visitation centers
- Involving therapists or social workers
- Encouraging your child to speak with a guardian ad litem or court-appointed psychologist
Can I ask the court to order monitored exchanges or evaluations?
Yes.
Courts often respond positively to requests for supervised visits, custody evaluations, or therapist reports if you can show concern for the child’s welfare.
These methods are legal, admissible, and often more persuasive than covert recordings.
Is it worth ever taking the risk of recording?
Only in extreme cases—such as when you have no other way to prove imminent danger to a child.
Even then, you should consult a lawyer first. Judges can be highly critical of recordings that appear to be staged, manipulated, or unethical.
How can I protect myself if I believe I’m being recorded?
You can minimise risk by:
- Communicating in writing where possible
- Avoiding emotional confrontations
- Having a neutral third-party present during exchanges
- Using secure communication platforms
If you suspect illegal recordings, legal action such as cease-and-desist letters or privacy complaints can be filed.
When should I consult a lawyer?
Immediately—especially before making a covert recording.
Legal counsel can help evaluate the admissibility, legality, and risk of your intended evidence.
A lawyer can also help you gather stronger, more ethical, and legally sound evidence that strengthens your custody position without jeopardising your case.
To help you
and to care
PacisLexis Family Law
Need expert legal help navigating covert recordings?
Navigating a custody battle is stressful, and the desire to protect your child can sometimes push you toward risky decisions. Covert recordings may seem like an easy way to “get proof,” but they carry serious legal and ethical pitfalls—especially across jurisdictions like common law and French civil law. Our team specialises in international family disputes and can guide you through every step of the process.
You can book a confidential, in-depth consultation within 48 hours—don’t let uncertainty put your parental rights at risk.
PacisLexis Family Law
Our separation & divorce articles
Conditional order
A conditional order is a legal document issued by a court outlining specific conditions that must be fulfilled before a final decision or decree is granted. It is commonly used in legal systems like those in England and other Common Law jurisdictions. Conditional orders are particularly prevalent in divorce cases, where they represent an intermediate stage confirming that the applicant is entitled to a divorce but must meet certain requirements before finalizing the process.
Changing a child arrangement order
When life circumstances change, so too might the needs of your family, particularly when it comes to child arrangement orders. Whether you’re navigating this issue under common law systems (like in the UK or US) or within French family law, understanding your options is crucial.
Ex-partner is refusing to leave the family home
When getting a divorce, spouses stop living together.
Most of the time, it’s a normal breakup process.
However, sometimes a partner refuses to leave the family home. This situation can become quickly tricky and also can lead to domestic violence.